| Comments | |
|
|
Hi McHaha,
I read this and whilst I understand the viewpoint character has been through a rough ride certain elements detracted from the story.
The slow build up into what happened makes you feel more like the girl is a whiny teenager rather than the strong woman she has had to have been to care for her brother and herself. Perhaps starting with some blunt sentences of the issues such as and this is only an idea...
Drugs, drink and neglect. Hardly the key attributes of a mother. Maybe that is why we never had that mother daughter bond the media paints so vividly.
An opening line like this might make the reader want to know more about the character and how hard their life has been rather than no mention of the issues until near the end. Although do not be disheartened because the chracter is a great idea.
The second thing for me was the plot if I can ever use that term correctly. You had the background information of her life and then in the last paragraph you seemed to have the entire plot rolled in on how she was searching on the intenet and then how she had to clean the house so the guy could move in and that he eventually did. Maybe you could twist this concept so she is telling the story of that and as it goes through she fills in the back story. Maybe even telling it to a social worker after this new guy has left and her mother has finally reached breaking point. Only some ideas but this at the moment seems more a back information on a character rather than a story.
Nonetheless I did think it was written quite well and that you had the information tightly in your grip so well done for not get lost with this but I hope my ideas can be of some help to you.
Regards
Gary
|
|
|
I really get the feeling that this all happened to you so, well done for writing it down and trying to make something positive and meaningful out of it all. I particulalry like this sentence 'We will make better lives for ourselves than she started us with'
It's important to try and make your reader like your voice and this made me like you. You could easily have imitated your mother so great that you want to do better!! Keep writing -it's therapeutic and I think you 'flow' really well.
|
|
|
I hear this as more of a diary writing. Very well written with great flow. If you are wanting to make a story of it try putting it in third person it might help. Don't stop writing you really hit the core and bring out the emotions.
|
|
|
I have critiqued your work as follows -
[Plot]
I thought your plot was good, exciting and distinguishable and had a central theme
I thought your plot moved forward in a structured way
I think this is a very good story
[Characters]
Your characters jumped off the page at me and attracted my attention
I felt your characters were real people with real lives, faults and merits
[Dialogue]
Your dialogue was natural
Your dialogue moved the scene forward
I could sense real conflict, attitudes and intentions from the dialogue
|