| Comments | |
|
|
Grampa,
I commend this simpler text, only that I have few points again (you can take it or not, it's up to you).
The fifth paragraph used so much S-V-O (subject-verb-object)
really really very tired
really really fast (must used only one "really" or even none will do)
the sky that was blue-- blue sky?
Congratulations for your fairly easy reading score.
|
|
|
Grampa Pogi
The hotdog dog Felix said it's too bland for his taste. That the narrative lost its cool and flavor. He was enjoying those Filipino spooks. He's not too happy about the change.
"You see," Felix said, "It's gotta be the vocabulary of the narrator. That's what I want to hear. Excuse me, but we hear the narrative and the speaking voice. Reading is just the means to convey the tone of the narrative. If the previous version is not readable enough, Barack's gotta do something about the education system."
I think Felix has got a point. But it's gonna cost trillions of moolah to overhaul the education system.
|
|
|
mnmnI,
I think simplicity with the tone would be great for a novel. It's not something about education system, it's about the convenience trend (what do people look for right now?). You can be simple without sacrificing the tone. Wouldn't that be great?
|
|
|
"it ain't so, Grampa Pogi. It hurts me reading it. Might as well go jaywalk with Leno," said Felix.
|
|
|
Haha! it's the tone that's missing, maybe could be inserted through sentence construction/ Grampa could do that he has strong emotions.
|
|
|
I don't know what you mean by simplicity of tone, Evita. There's no such thing. Tone is not simple. Tone in a story is the author's voice distinct to the characters voices. The characters may be laughing; but the author may be sarcastic. From tone, the reader grasps the real meaning of the laugh.
First, it's readability. Then it's simplicity. Which is which? Readability is not the same as simplicity. And the words are subjective . . . abstract. What's readable to one may not be readable to another. But of course, Grampa Pogi may also write a children's book for the 35-year old young laddes.
|
|
|
The tone of this rewrite is like a lampoon and sarcasm.
|
|
|
Hi Evita,
Let me direct you to this phrase >>> Please note this is not for critiquing. However, if you feel like it, go ahead,
Grampa
|
|
|
Hi M n m n I,
Here's the gist of the whole article >>> for the benefit of those who had a hard time understanding regular words; words that they perceived as really-difficult-to-comprehend words.
:-)
Grampa
|
|
|
MnmnI,
>>> The tone of this rewrite is like a lampoon and sarcasm.
You got it :-)
Grampa
|
|
|
mnmnI,
I didn't say "simplicity of tone" I said "simplicity" and "tone". If sharing what I learned from other books is a crime. Then I will not speak anymore. What I received from sharing is sarcasm and all, which I don't expect from people like you.
|
|
|
I know I am younger than both of you, but that doesn't mean I can't share anything.
|
|
|
Nothing personal, Evita
Just tone
and you got it
very clearly
|
|
|
I haven't met you, Evita
and I was just born yesterday
It's not the issue of sharing or not sharing
I'd prefer that you share what you really think
not from information from a book that seems like you take at face value
As Caine (Grasshopper) said in Kung Fu (the tv series)
"I seek not to know the answers, but to understand the questions."
Read the book
Ask the right questions
Find the right answers
Then share what you really think
|
|
|
Ok mnmnI, wisdom understood and accepted. Maybe the gist of all what I said is that, we need to be open for learning and we can have that from other authors too, if we think that we are good, then probably we can be best.
|
|
|
Grampa, this is the funniest thing that I have read for a very long time. I laughed so much that I thought that I was going to give myself a serious injury.
Absolutely brilliant.
I wish I had thought of it.
|
|
|
Evita
Like you I'm open minded; but not to the extent that my brains fall out
That's why I say there's more to readability that meets the eye
I want you to know that undertones lurk in writing
And most of all, I want you to be the best you can be
|
|
|
mnmnI, thank you because you want me to be the best that I can be, I listen to your points about readability and it's clear to me, and don't worry I will remember your advice, although I can't promise to follow fully. My readers are the first consideration in whatever I write and I can't give them a piece with a fairly difficult reading score. This doesn't mean, though, that you undertone your work.
|
|
|
Churchmouse,
I was in pain so much when I was writing it that I thought
I was going to give myself a really, really serious injury.
;-)
Grampa
|
|
|
What have you done, Grampa? After mnmnI hoping you and Evita didn't get married on Valentine's Sunday, he and Evita are now having some sort of a tryst, only this time it's a meeting of their minds. But that's good for they're communicating, they'll be able to sort out anything and everything. Evita, just like you, mnmnI was just sharing his knowledge. He has given too many sweet comments on your writings, remember? Anyway, Grampa, I like easy reading but it wouldn't hurt if every now and then I bump into some high-falluting words. Also, this chapter is now stamped for reading after all the comments received.
|